In September 1964, seven men handed the President of the United States a report. It ran 888 pages, with 26 volumes of testimony and exhibits behind it, and it said one man, acting alone, had killed John Kennedy. Fifteen years later a committee of Congress read that report, looked at a great deal its authors never saw, and concluded that the President was probably killed as the result of a conspiracy.
Both reports are still official. Nobody in the government has ever been asked to choose between them, and nobody has volunteered. I find that pretty remarkable.
Heroes' Path has opened a nine-part series about the space between those two answers, JFK: The Questions That Still Endure, and Episode 1 is now online. A few of the things it covers surprised me.
Kennedy kept a private line to Nikita Khrushchev that went around the State Department, the Pentagon and the CIA. Some of those messages were carried by Georgi Bolshakov, an officer of Soviet military intelligence working under diplomatic cover in Washington. One of Khrushchev's first long letters reached the White House folded inside a newspaper.
Allen Dulles ran the CIA until Kennedy pushed him out after the Bay of Pigs. Three years later Dulles sat on the commission investigating Kennedy's murder. In 1976 a Senate committee found that the CIA never told that commission about its own plots to kill Fidel Castro, plots that began while Dulles was director.
Six weeks before Dallas, Kennedy signed National Security Action Memorandum 263, dated October 11, 1963, which called for the first thousand American advisors to leave Vietnam by the end of that year. And Lyndon Johnson, in an interview with The Atlantic published in 1973 after his death, said he had never believed that Oswald acted alone.
Then there is Jim Garrison. He stood six foot six. In the Second World War he flew artillery-spotting missions in a light plane over Europe and walked through Dachau shortly after it was liberated. As District Attorney of New Orleans he did something almost nobody else did: he read all 26 volumes of the Warren Commission's evidence, and he concluded that the report did not match its own exhibits.
People ask why we'd spend nine evenings on something that happened 63 years ago. In 1960 the American people chose a President. In 1963 that choice was undone in a few seconds on a Dallas street, and the country was never given a full accounting of how or why. A republic depends on informed citizens, and you're owed the evidence before you reach your own conclusions. So every claim in the series carries a label, and a theory gets called a theory every time, including our own. We're not going to tell you who killed John Kennedy. We are going to put the files in front of you, one at a time.
Jeff Steinberg met with Garrison in New Orleans while Garrison was writing On the Trail of the Assassins, and Garrison mailed him the chapters on carbon paper as he wrote them. The first time they met, Garrison took him to dinner at Antoine's in the French Quarter, and every head in the restaurant turned. Jeff tells the rest of that story in the episode.
Read the full essay on Substack: https://heroespath.substack.com/p/two-official-answers-sixty-three
By John Fenzel, founder and CEO of Heroes' Path Foundation